The Party in the Woods – Fiona McPhillips

Published By: Bantam
Pages: 320
Released On: 07/01/2027

“Annie couldn’t have known that this was the last time they would all be together, the last time anything would ever be the same again.”

When Sean Salinger vanished without trace after a rave in the Dublin mountains in 2001, his friends never wanted to talk about that night again.

Twenty-two years later, Annie Fagan is still asking questions. And when a grisly discovery reframes Sean’s disappearance as murder, she’s pulled back into the circle she thought she’d left behind for good. Back to a world of strobing lights, pulse-pounding basslines and the alluring chaos of the dancefloor.

But digging up the past means exposing who her friends really are – and what they did to keep their secrets buried. Because someone at that party knows what happened to Sean.

Someone who has killed before.
Someone who will kill again . . .

*****

Thanks to NetGalley and Bantam for the advanced copy of this title in return for an honest review.

This is the first of Fiona’s books I’m reading. I do have a copy of When We Were Silent but I haven’t read it yet.

I had positive and negative thoughts about this one, but let me start with a positive.

It flits between the present time and then two decades previously, when “the thing” happened. I know some people don’t get on with multiple timelines and POVs but I think its a great way to tell two linked but separate stories. I think I preferred the now scenes to the then scenes. I just found the scenes set in the past were a bit too chaotic.

My main issue was with the characters. There’s just too many of them. Now I am personally terrible at remembering names so I know that’s a me issue. But I struggled to keep on top of who was who and how they related to each other. And that made it really difficult to connect with any of them, which then made it a struggle to care about any of them. And I think that was my main issue. The story was interesting enough, and the tension and the dual timelines etc. But the complete confusion over the characters really took me out of it and I struggled to lose myself in it.

A lot of this book revolves around the rave scene, the drug scene, and neither of those are my scene at all, so the only understand I have comes from other books. And it did feel uncomfortable reading about it, but I think in this book it worked, because there’s this feeling of being out of control, not remembering things, not knowing who or what to believe. I think it would appeal more to readers who have some experience in the rave scene because they can put themselves in the action, but it kept me at arms length.

It is very much a slow burn psychological mystery. I like a slow burn thriller, and this does do that. I think it was on the verge of possibly being too slow but overall she’s found the balance.

It got better again near the end. I still didn’t really know who was who but I felt it was a satisfying ending – I just would have liked less characters, more tension, and just more in the middle 60% of the book.

Leave a Reply